VWR Winter meeting
A duty to disobey?
Should the law be disobeyed when it is perceived to be unjust – by judges or civil servants in particular, but also more generally? The childcare benefits scandal in the Netherlands is one of many historical and current, national and international examples which have raise this question. We will be examining the issue at the VWR 2022 winter meeting.
In different talks, we will analyse or consider the question of a duty to disobey in a more specific light. Here, one might for example think of
- Are there differences regarding the duty to disobey between civil servants, judges and the general population?
- Is there a difference between refusing general conscription and refusing to apply the law as a civil servant?
- Is the duty to disobey, if it exists, a legal or a moral one? What implications would this have?
- What is the meaning of the doctrine of contra legem is this regard? Is a decision contra legem a form of disobedience or not?
- What is the relationship between a supposed duty to disobey and the rule of law?
- Can the Toeslagenaffaire provide an angle from which we could contemplate in- and exclusion from the law – the parent who makes a mistake; the civil servant who might decide not to follow the law to the letter?
- How can conscientious objectors account for their actions?
- How can a community demand of civil servants not to follow the law?
- Where do the questions of legal philosophy (‘when is disobedience mandatory?’) and politics and political accountability (‘what kind of community seeks accountability at the level of administration and jurisdiction, but not of politics?’) meet?
- (If there is a duty to disobey), how can we offer those who disobey (and e.g. whistleblowers) better protection?
- Does it matter whether the law that ought to be disobeyed is municipal, national, regional, or international?
These questions are illustrative and non-exhaustive.
Programme
11.15 | General Members Meeting VWR (NL) in room KAP 1.028 (entrance Kapoenstraat 2) |
12.00 | Lunch |
13.00 | Opening of the meeting (in plenary) in room KAP 1.028 (entrance Kapoenstraat 2) |
13.15 |
Dutch Session:
|
15.15 | Coffee break |
15.45 |
English Session:
|
17.15 | Closing and drinks |
Relevant links
Also read
-
30 Oct 01 Nov09:00 - 17:00
The conference will feature high-quality scholarly perspectives and theoretical investigations into the relationship or correlation between Narratives, Frontier Technologies, and the Law, with the objective of providing valuable insights for international legal scholars to analyse and conceptualise the evolution of technology law. The range of topics covered include ethical & legal challenges, bias & fairness, innovation & governance in technology, emerging technology & governance, sustainability & the environment, and international perspectives.
-
04 Nov 05 Nov14:15 - 11:30
The seminar is to discuss the evolving role of principles in EU environmental law. It will examine how different principles evolve and operate together, in order to identify the foundational roles they play in the achievement of the Treaty objective of a high level of environmental protection.
-
08 Nov13:00 - 17:30
YOUNGIS is a network of young scholars from Dutch Universities, specialising in criminal law. The group is embedded within the Netherlands National Group – Gezelschap voor Internationaal Strafrecht (GIS) of the International Association of Penal Law/Association International de Droit Pénal (AIDP).